Long story short. My wife who has moved out stated that her wedding ring was “stolen” a few months ago and last month reported that a big jar of coins that we had been collecting for 7 years was also stolen. She has done so many deceitful things that I strongly suspect she has taken both these things. She now is stating that she wants me to file both of these things on our home insurance and give her half the money from the claim ($3200 ring minus $1000 deductible). She has had an affair and I have proof of that. I am wondering if fault plays any part in the wedding rings or are they considered gifts regardless of divorce fault? In other words, b/c she is at fault for this divorce, do I get the wedding ring back that I gave her during our marriage ceremony?